Girls and women in India are sacrificial goats!

-
Image
Surprised by my blog article title!!! But the title is factual and not exaggerated. Though women are educated, they are not truly empowered. The reason is that the strongly patriarchal mentality still continues to exist in India majorly. When people claim that things are changing, I feel like laughing. Because at the grassroot level, nothing great has changed. There may be isolated cases of women who are independent in the true sense of the word and hence happy. This might be seen in some urban areas. But in rural areas, it is the same old story. Women are pushed into marriages that they do not like. Their voice or opinion is not heard. Even parents are insensitive and deaf to their voices. Sad but true. And truth is always bitter .  I have done a research in Uttarakhand and found that 99% of the women are unhappy in marriages. They were forced into it and they continue to toil with no inner happiness. The happiness is just the false happiness you get when you just fall in line wit...
Post a Comment

Human Milk Banks and Ethics!!! Should human milk donating mothers be compensated?

-

Human milk banks have cropped up in various countries of the world because studies showed that mother's milk was better than formula milk for preterm babies. It prevents necrotising colitis in children. Cochrane analysis has also shown similar findings. But in this, donor mothers spend their time and efforts to make available the milk for other babies. So the question is that should these mothers be compensated for it? 

Pros of compensation for donating mothers

Mothers who are donating their breast milk for other babies are taking out time out of their busy schedules to do so. Besides, there are efforts and sometimes pain involved in pumping breast milk. It is a sort of sacrifice that the mother is doing and she is doing some good deed. So it is very important that she be compensated for this work she is doing for society and other mothers and their children. It cannot be just put as a form of nobility and sacrifice and merely lauded with no monetary appreciation.

Human breast milk donation [Source: What to Expect]

 

Money has an important place in the life of everyone and hence money given to such mothers could be used in places where she finds it necessary. Besides, the introduction of monetary compensation would motivate more mothers to come forward and donate her breast milk for other babies. This would lead to sufficiency of breast milk for such babies and the human milk banks would be able to meet the demands adequately. Mothers so compensated would not feel cheated and depressed that their breast milk is being harnessed for other babies. 

Cons of monetary compensation

Some people who are skeptical of providing money as a motivation for such mothers talk about altruism and its use in breast milk donation. Karleen Gribble, PhD, an adjunct associate professor in the School of Nursing and Midwifery at Western Sydney University in Australia told: 

“The reasons are centered around altruism. They want to help somebody,”

“But if you put money into it, then you’re adding something. You know, you have quite a different motivation.”

A healthy baby [Source: Mothers Milk Bank]

Some fear that the motivation may end up with greed and some mothers might give away more milk and this would lead to starvation of their own babies. There are also chances of adulteration of donated breast milk with water or cow's milk due to the same factor. Pediatrics journal had published a study that showed that 10% of such donated breast milk samples had cow's milk in it. But does this element of greed not happen with other forms of donations such as blood, organ, tissue, sperms but the monetary package still continues in those cases!

The situation in the USA

In the USA, non-profit organizations and institutes do not pay the donors but the for-profit human milk banks do pay the donors. Such money is also exchanged during the direct sharing of milk amongst mothers. 

Besides, the non-profit human milk banks in the USA charge the recipients $5 per ounce of milk donated. This is to meet the cost of screening, processing and storing of the donated human milk. Dr Lawrence Noble from Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York said: 

“Although the milk is donated, there are expenses, such as milk processing, milk distribution, and buying of pasteurizers, freezers, and bottles,”

Donated breast milk and preterm babies [Source: Mothers Milk Bank]

Some of these recipient mothers have insurance plans that make the payments on their behalf. There has been a controversy raised on this as well that says that milk should be given based on the medical necessity and not on the financial capacity of the mothers. 

Everything said and done, the mothers who donate breast milk should not be taken for granted and made to donate based on talks of altruism and nobility. Besides, all priceless commodities carry a price tag and human breast milk is also one of them!!! Proper supervision and monitoring would prevent misuse of this useful donation and when a sperm donor, blood, and an organ donor is compensated, why not a human breast milk donor??? Let us stop putting anything related to a mother in the socket of nobility!!!

Also, read https://lifensocietyblog.blogspot.com/2020/11/new-study-italy-origin-covid-19.html

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Morton's toe: Everything you need to know about your longer second toe

-
Image
 Often, one notices that the second toe of some people is longer than the great toe. People say different things for it. Many of them say that it implies that the owner of such a longer second toe is a dominant, creative, energetic person in real life and very ambitious and peace and happiness-loving. But no one has tried to understand the reason, science, medicine and problems of having such a toe. It is called as Morton’s toe or Greek foot.  What is a Greek foot? Many people in the world have a longer second toe of the foot. Such feature may be on one side or in both the feet. It is called Morton’s toe or Greek foot. The other names for it are Morton’s foot or royal toe. But the reason is not the second toe is longer but the fact is that the first metatarsal below the great toe is shorter. Thus it is not due to the faulty phalanges but due to the difference in height of the metatarsals. Since the second metatarsal is relatively longer than the first metatarsal, the joint at ...
Read more

There can be no universal forgiveness! It never exists!

-
Image
Forgiveness or pardon means clearing off the feelings of resentment or revenge towards the offender. In most contexts it implies giving up any expectation of justice. People justify this act of forgiveness from a religious point of view and psychologists justify it as an act that would bring peace to the victim. But my experience tells me that both religion as well as psychologists are absolutely wrong in asking a victim to forgive the evil person. This act is bad from a society point of view and would lead to a rise in crimes and unhappiness. Let me explain in depth with examples. 1. I have a friend in the UK. She is originally from Nigeria. She has two siblings who are married with children and she herself is single and childless. In the year 2009, she had gone to her hometown. There her siblings tortured her physically and mentally and put her under house arrest. They did not want to give her any ancestral property and assets. She managed to free herself with the help of a friend an...
Read more

Girls and women in India are sacrificial goats!

-
Image
Surprised by my blog article title!!! But the title is factual and not exaggerated. Though women are educated, they are not truly empowered. The reason is that the strongly patriarchal mentality still continues to exist in India majorly. When people claim that things are changing, I feel like laughing. Because at the grassroot level, nothing great has changed. There may be isolated cases of women who are independent in the true sense of the word and hence happy. This might be seen in some urban areas. But in rural areas, it is the same old story. Women are pushed into marriages that they do not like. Their voice or opinion is not heard. Even parents are insensitive and deaf to their voices. Sad but true. And truth is always bitter .  I have done a research in Uttarakhand and found that 99% of the women are unhappy in marriages. They were forced into it and they continue to toil with no inner happiness. The happiness is just the false happiness you get when you just fall in line wit...
Read more